The Buddy Holly Story was a remarkable movie, not because it was terribly accurate (it wasn’t). Some of the best music biopics, like The Buddy Holly Story, feature the movie cast doing the singing and playing. In a rare stroke of fortune, Gary Busey was cast as the perfect Buddy Holly. He could sing enough like the rock and roll legend, and with some curly hair and glasses, Busey fit the bill.
The “Clear Lake Medley” is made up of Buddy’s greatest hits like “Peggy Sue”, “That’ll Be the Day”, “Oh Boy”, “Maybe Baby”, and “Not Fade Away”. They’re amped-up, made to sound like the live concert experience. Busey’s more manic in this setting than the old familiar studio versions.
The most interesting track, possibly, is the a-Capella “I’m Gonna Love You Too”, with just Gary Busey’s voice. You can’t fake it in that setting. The guy managed to sound enough like Buddy Holly through this whole soundtrack that you often drift away and forget that’s what it is. The suspension of disbelief is complete.
All this and you’ll get a collection of some pretty amazing songs too. You’ll know most of ’em, including “Everyday” and “Whole Lotta Shakin’ Goin’ On”. As seen in the film, “Everyday” is a slow, ballady version. That is certainly compensated for by the “Roller Rink Medley”, another adrenaline-pumped live set.
Truly a great soundtrack and a worthy addition for Buddy Holly fans.