GUEST REVIEW: The Winery Dogs – The Winery Dogs (by Jon Wilmenius)

After hearing so much praise for The Winery Dogs, I finally bought a copy.  I decided for now there was no point in writing a review:  After all, Jon Wilmenius already said it all.  So for my own review, all I’ll write is:  “What he said!”  Enjoy this review from Jon’s own excellent site, Music and Festival Reviews, reprinted with his kind permission.

Read the original here.

GUEST REVIEW by: Jon Wilmenius

THE WINERY DOGS – The Winery Dogs (2013 Loud & Proud)

Way back in the late 80′s / early 90′s supergroups were popping up like mushrooms in your garden. Bands like Bad English, Mr Big and Badlands had big success with the odd album or two before breaking up, but when the 90′s grunge era took over, supergroups were as rare as money on your bank account. Today, things have turned around and with the music industry looking like it does, musicians are forming different projects and bands with each other like never before. One guy that seems to involved a little everywhere are former Dream Theater drummer Mike Portnoy. As of now he is involved in no less than four different bands, Transatlantic, Flying Colors, Adrenaline Mob and now this thing. When The Winery Dogs started out in 2011, they consisted of Portnoy, bassist Billy Sheehan of Mr Big (formerly of Talas and David Lee Roth) and guitarist / lead singer John Sykes (Tygers Of Pan Tang, Thin Lizzy, Whitensake, Blue Murder), but since Sykes seemed to have too much on his mind, he decided to split and was replaced by multi musician and guitar player / lead singer Richie Kotzen, who also has a successful solo career going on, but also a former member of Poison, Mr Big and Forty Deuce.

Without hearing a note of their music, just by looking at the line up makes expectations rise like a virgin’s dong at the Playboy Mansion. That means that nothing worse than ‘great’ would be acceptable for this trio’s debut release. Now, I don’t know how much music that was written with Sykes in the band and how much of it that ended up on this album, but the fact is, Kotzen is all over this record. Kotzen’s solo career sky rocketed after he got the boot from Poison, at least quality wise and even a tone-deaf  could spot his style miles away. Just listen to Poison’s Native Tongue, the best album they ever released, and you’ll hear pretty fast which songs he brought to the table. He really should re-record them as a solo artist someday. So, if you’re a fan of Kotzen’s, this album is a no-brainer – as a matter of fact, it really should be a no-brainer for any a rock fan to buy this CD, because this is amazing stuff. “Elevate” kicks this album into motion with a bang, a rootsy rocker that sounds a lot like Richie’s solo stuff only with Sheehan’s famous and personal bass sound and Portnoy’s heavy groove. “Desire” follows and it is a brilliant tune, full of catchiness and groovy rhythms, “I’m No Angel” has a fantastic refrain and a killer melody, you’re stuck after the first chorus, on “The Other Side”, Sheehan and Portnoy totally rules the groove and the bass and drums are both one and separated at the same time and they give us a brilliant blues ballad in “You Saved Me”. It has a bit of a U2 – feel and Kotzen sings the hell out of it. The guy has got some feel, to say the least.

Both “Not Impossible” and “One More Time” has a lot of Kotzen over them and I find myself thinking that they probably would have been a great fit on his last album 24 Hours. “Six Feet Deeper” has a major swing to it and it strikes me that this is the first album I have heard where Mike Portnoy plays rock ‘n’ roll like this. I mean, he’s an amazing drummer, but his skills has always been in progressive metal where he doesn’t groove that much. This album shows that Portnoy is a lot more all round than people might think. “Criminal” on the other hand, is a heavy piece – not a far cry from how a Kotzen fronted Mr Big would sound. “The Dying” is a ballad, but it leans way more towards heaviness than anything else which is really cool – and it is a great song. The album ends with “Regret”, a classic Kotzen ballad, very bluesy in a 70′s style. Wow! This really is a super trio and they have made one hell of a debut album and hopefully enough people will buy this to convince the guys to keep this project alive. Another thing, has Billy Sheehan and Mike Portnoy ever played with such a groove like they do here? I mean, they are both ace players and with Kotzen, groove is in his blood, but on here Sheehan and Portnoy really makes the rhythm section swing. When we’re writing January 2014 and making a list on the best albums of 2013, this album will no doubt be up there as a contender for the number one spot. Jon says: Get this!

Jon Wilmenius (9/10)




  1. Excellent review. Hooray for guest shots! The only trouble is, you’re just as bad as Mike, bringing up bands I didn’t know I needed to hear until I read your write-ups!

    Hahaha “virgin’s dong at the Playboy Mansion.” Oh man, I think that might enter my lexicon when speaking to people. Hahahaha well-played.


        1. …and sometimes you need to pull out the chainsaw!

          Speaking of which, I’m hoping you’ll use it soon when I review Poison’s Hollyweird and Bon Jovi’s The Circle…


        2. ;)

          I’m cleansing myself of them right now. Listening to and reviewing the Dio tribute. Almost done the first draft. If all goes well I’ll put it up after I’m done with the Week of Rockin’ Movies.


    1. Thanks. Well, I usually only review new albums, where Mike does older stuff. I love reading Mike’s reviews of older albums, especially as he and I often have similar taste in music.
      But if you visit my site now and again there’s more where this came from. Come on in and I’ll make you poor… Moaaaahahahaa! ;)


      1. Yeah that’s true. I guess that’s sort of becoming my “niche”. Since joining WordPress 2 years ago I feel like I need to REALLY know an album inside and out before I review it. That’s probably just personal neurosis. But you guys all do such a great job, and I am a perfectionist, so I guess that’s part of it! I like to know the album completely and then review and it takes time, because feelings change.


  2. This is cool, Mike. As I said, you’re welcome to do this whenever you feel like it.
    Dreams In The Witch House?


  3. I’ve held out long enough for this …Excellent review Jon…so now I’m gonna purchase the deluxe edition on April 15th with the bonus disc a live show from Japan……
    Always dug some of Kotzens solo stuff esp that tune Socialite!
    And I have sumthin for power trios!


    1. Mother Head’s Family Reunion. What a magnificent record. And even better is the folloow up – The Return Of MHFR. Probably the best Kotzen album ever.


  4. Excellent review (though, John Sykes was never a part of The Winery Dogs, he was meant for a separate “project”)… All everything you hear on this album is PURE Richie Kotzen , with Billy Sheehan, and Mike Portnoy. Richie Kotzen is an incredibly talented songwriter, vocalist, guitar player, and performer. Thrilled to see the rest of the world is waking up to this fact long known by his fans.
    Thanks again for this great review and spreading the word!


    1. I know that, Michelle. I got myself set right in the comments area on my site. Mike Portnoy even mentioned it on his FB page so I apologized for my bad research. Thing is I googled them and got the info from Wikipedia and I guess they were wrong.

      When it comes to Kotzen I’ve been a huge fan of his since he wrote the best album Poison ever recorded. I would love for him to re-record some of those songs on his own.


      1. No worries… These guys are all awesome. And yes, I would love to see Richie take some of those NT songs with him.
        Stay tuned for a new solo album coming this year. Hope you review it as well. Richie deserves the best.


  5. Mike,thanks to,Jon’s review I finally got around to getting this(deluxe) the live disc I listened to first and it cooks….
    Just Letting u know u have to buy 2 copies!


Rock a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s