#413: Just for the record, Meat’s gonna put it down (Guest shot)

RECORD STORE TALES MkII: Getting More Tale
#413: Just for the record, Meat’s gonna put it down

By special request of Aaron at the KMA, yesterday I ranked all the Marillion studio albums in order of preference (see #412: Just for the record, I’m gonna put it down).  It’s not an easy thing to do, because any band with two distinct phases (and lead singers) is going to have lovers and haters of both, as well as fans who can accept both equally.

During Sausagefest weekend 2015, I discussed my already-completed list with Uncle Meat, who also wanted to take part.  He has his own feelings about Marillion’s discography.  In fact he only listed six albums.  Meat is very much a “Phase One” fan, a follower of Fish who had a hard time accepting the changes that occurred after Seasons End.  It’s important to note that Seasons End was mostly written (musically) with Fish.  After that album, the band had to come up with new material for the new singer, and that is when they started to write very differently from before.  It’s not Steve Hogarth’s fault, in Meat’s eyes, just the way the band wrote for and with him.

Here are Uncle Meat’s top Marillion albums, without commentary.  He’s going top down:

MISPLACED1. Misplaced Childhood (1985)

CLUTCHING2. Clutching at Straws (1987)

FUGAZI3. Fugazi (1984)

SCRIPT4. Script For A Jester’s Tear (1983)

SEASONS5. Seasons End (1989)

6. Vigil In A Wilderness of Mirrors – Fish (1990)

How’s that for a “Big Wedge”? More Marillion tomorrow!

Advertisements

17 comments

  1. This is awesome, you guys share (in slightly different order) your top 3! Couldn’t get much more of a recommendation than that.

    Again, I appreciate all of this Marillion listing effort. Cheers to you for setting all this up, and thanks to Meat for his input!

    Liked by 1 person

      1. I’ll have a look for the 2CD sets. I have Misplaced Childhood in the single CD version, as you well know! Worth replacing?

        #6 here isn’t Marillion? Just Marillion guy? Without the commentary I have no real idea… I just looked it up and his debut solo record? People seem to like it, it’s quite expensive on the the Amazons. I don’t know enough about the band to know whether this counts as a Marillion record or not (I’m guessing not). But he must’ve included it here because it’s close enough and it kicks ass? What’s the story?

        Liked by 1 person

        1. I think what he is trying to say with his list, is that in his world there are only six Marillion albums, and the solo album is more a Marillion album than the ones he doesn’t count.

          He’s got a valid point because the lyrics were all written for Marillion songs, and the cover art by Mark Wilkinson continues where they left off in Marillion. I may be wrong but this painting may have been done for the next Marillion album.

          Like

  2. Didn’t some great mind once suggest that you use Just For The Record as a blog title?!

    Loved this but my collection stops after Season’s End. I’d swop Script and Fugazi in your rankings too – you definitely got the #1 spot on. Mark Wilkinson’s favourite one too!

    Liked by 1 person

      1. He’s got 1 and 2 the wrong way around, I’m with you there Mike. I think Vigil’s a really good LP, but I’d have B-Sides over it most days. I haven’t heard Vigil for hundreds of years, I’ll give it a spin tonight.

        Liked by 1 person

  3. I can dig what you are saying here. If taken as a whole it is possible to just include the Fish era in your fandom. I heard Vigil ages ago and it didn’t connect with me, there was something missing for me, probably Rothery. This era for Marillion as truly one of a kind. The Hogarth era really kinda runs into itself and its difficult to distinguish one album from the other, and that is JUST not the case with the Fish era.

    personally I go..
    Clutching (top 10 all time)
    Fugazi
    Childhood
    Script.
    Brief Encounter
    La Gazza
    BSides

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I like these list. I stayed away from live stuff because that’s a pandora’s box I didn’t wanna open, but you’ve got some great stuff here. Only thing missing is the immortal Market Square Heroes EP…oh no wait, you’ve got B-Sides! You’re all good!

      Like

Rock a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s