Most bands have stinker albums somewhere in their history. For Styx, that would be their sadly disappointing reunion album Brave New World. Styx were not exactly in harmony with lead singer Dennis DeYoung, and this would be his last album with the band.
The most obvious evidence of the dischord in the band is that Brave New World sounds like two groups. In one: Tommy Shaw and James Young. In the other: Dennis DeYoung. The songs with Shaw and Young singing have hardly any DeYoung, and vice-versa. It sounds as if they could find no common ground. Far removed from the days of old, when even a disagreeing band could sound like a group.
The single “Everything is Cool” is by far the hardest rocking and best song. There are a few decent ones, such as the exotic title track, but nothing that the band would still perform on stage today. The most Styx-sounding track is Dennis’ ballad “While There’s Still Time”. That’s right, a ballad! Shaw’s “Just Fell In” is also swell, with a 1950s vibe. Other songs such as “Number One” are annoyingly modernized. The late 1990s is not a period that has aged well in music. The production, the mish-mashing of styles…Styx seemed to pick up on the bad parts of these trends. Too much programming, too many samples. Not enough Dennis! DeYoung can only be distinctly detected on a handful of tracks, mostly ballads. These are often the best songs…all but “Hip Hop-cracy”, which is so painfully 1999.
It’s kind of a shame that the Styx reunion sputtered the way it did, but the silver lining was their second life with Lawrence Gowan. The Styx reunion album was sadly a bust.