REVIEW: Fish – Kettle of Fish 88-98 (1998)

scan_20170105FISH – Kettle of Fish 88-98  (1998 Roadrunner)

Kettle of Fish, the “best of” Derek W. Dick, is the first and only CD I’ve ever had stolen from me.

I got it cheap, something like $7 brand new, from one of our stores.  Then a year later, someone stole the CD player from my car, with the Fish CD inside.  Emotionally distraught, I sought to replace it right away.  The best I could do was $30 for a replacement copy shipped from Fish’s official site.  How crushing.  I wondered with bemusement what the thieves thought of Fish’s progressive rock poetry.  I imagine they tossed the disc into a snowbank.

While Kettle of Fish is no replacement for Fish’s debut solo album Vigil In a Wilderness of Mirrors, it is a fine collection of the man’s first decade as a solo artist and an enjoyable listen through.  It also boasts a nice colourful booklet with all the relevant singles covers, photos, lyrics and liner notes by Derek W. Dick.  Incidentally my original copy was missing pages.  I wonder if that is how it ended up in our store?  A defective run, sent off to a clearance somewhere, that eventually found its way into one of our warehouses.  Missing pages notwithstanding, it’s an excellent packaging job.

Since the album is made up of singles (and two new songs that we’ll get to), you will always find that critical deep album cuts are missing.  “Vigil” was not a single, but it’s one of Fish’s greatest achievements.  There’s no “The Company”.  “I Like to Watch” is missing in action.  Instead the CD is arranged to give roughly equal time to all of Fish’s output to date.  Tracks from Internal ExileSuits, Yin, Yang and Sunsets On Empire are given fair representation.

Some of the best tracks are the lesser known variety.  “Brother 52” is hip and modern, yet still obviously Fish.  The loopy drums are perfect for the track, lending it a 90’s groove with a rock integrity throughout.  The spoken word parts of “Brother 52” are sometimes distracting, but are by and large incorporated as part of the song.  A vibrant violin solo goes for the kill and that’s all she wrote.  The Celtic jig “Internal Exile” is another immediate favourite.  The lyrics evolved from a song Marillion were working on for their unfinished fifth LP called “Exile on Princess Street”.  It was the kind of stuff Marillion were getting sick of. According to Dick, “The lyrics started to follow a more political lean with a distinctly Scottish nationalist tone. The band weren’t happy.”

I saw a blue umbrella in Princes Street Gardens,
Heading out west for the Lothian Road,
An Evening News stuffed deep in his pocket,
Wrapped up in his problems to keep away the cold.

Grierson’s spirit haunts the dockyards,
Where the only men working are on the documentary crews,
Shooting film as the lines get longer,
As the seams run out, as the oil runs dry.

The finished lyrics make you feel it. Yes the music for “Internal Exile” is bright and chipper, with a tin whistle to take your worry away. It sounds nothing like the morose music Marillion coupled it with. Maybe that’s what made all the difference.

Tracks including “Credo”, “Big Wedge” and “State of Mind” are varied and of very high quality.  You might think you put on an unknown 80s Phil Collins single if you play “Big Wedge” unannounced.  Of the two new songs recorded for the album, “Chasing Miss Pretty” is the most enjoyable.  It’s simple silly light rock for the summer time.  Fish seems to have dropped the ball a little bit on the lyrics, but “Chasing Miss Pretty” is still far more poetic than anything Jon Bon Jovi has ever written.

First of all, I caught her reflection in the window of the pharmacy store,
There I was locked up in my pick-up in the rush hour on the Delaware road.
It must have been the scent of her perfume or the glimpse of that French lingerie,
A product of my imagination, I blame it all on a hot summer’s day.

Unfortunately the other new song “Mr. Buttons” is forgettable musically and lyrically.  A song about hackers and e-crime in 1998 is going to sound quaint in 2017.

The weight of Fish’s early career casts a large shadow on everything the man has done since.  Vigil was a triumph in every way for the singer.  The early songs generally outshine the later songs.  You will find favourites in the later material, but the early stuff will probably keep you coming back for another listen.  The new songs are a nice add-on, and the packaging makes it worth a go, especially if you don’t own any Fish.  Proceed!

4.5/5 stars


Roger doesn't appear happy with his Fish CD.

Roger doesn’t appear happy with his Fish CD.


  1. Fish, eh..for me it’s still either Misplaced Childhood or Clutching at Straws. but I do remember buying Vigil In a Wilderness of Mirrors when it came out and liking it.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I’ve got a good batch of the solo albums and a double-disc comp so looks like the only songs I’m missing here are the two new ones… And it doesn’t sound like I’m missing much eh? I like his solo stuff but I agree with you, I don’t go back to it nearly as much as his early stuff.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Interesting to read about the distribution by year – as you said, roughly the same amount of tracks from each era.
    And when I read about ‘quaint’ Mr. Buttons (nice word), it reminded me of a Britney Spears song from her 1001 debut album, ’email my heart’ – seems a little strange as a name in 2017!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. One of the problems with being a bit current with political shenanigans or the goings on in lyrics etc, eh? Tends to make songs sound a wee bit dated…

    Still, this one sounds like a really good introduction to Fish. Like Marillion, I really need to explore further.

    Sounds like the theft of the CD had a silver lining, though? You got the complete booklet, huh?

    Out of interest, more upset about the CD than the CD player?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I got a complete booklet.

      And yeah can you tell I was more upset about the CD than the player? I could go and buy a new player and did that afternoon. The Fish CD was harder to replace, and I missed it more.

      The political stuff, I don’t know, some of that has to be timeless? “The fish are few…” I know that’s an issue here in Canada on the east coast.

      Liked by 1 person

  5. Much as I love the man I kind of lost interest after Internal Exile. Vigil is a great LP though and I saw him on that tour too, a slightly out-of-place Stage Dolls supported him.


      1. There are re-recordings on Yin and Yang which reflect where Fish was musically at the time, so some of them work great and some of them just work. I assume that rerecordings of Marillion material was for business reasons. It’s before Steve Wilson came in with his “Groove Training” during “Sunsets…” so it’s all quite laid back and a bit West Coast (not in a bad way).
        There was a corking interview CD called “The Funny Farm Interviews” that came out as a promo thing (I think) at the time which is great. Fish tells loads of old stories from his past in his usual heart-on-sleeve way and he rambles on for nearly 80 minutes in a fashion that makes you think you’re sitting in the pub with him. Incidentally, he did a similar CD when “Sunsets…” came out which was pretty good, although not as focussed on history and career.
        It’s a shame that the 90s seemed to consistently try to kick Fish’s arse. He never got the breaks, the poor sod.


Rock a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s