ELF – Carolina County Ball (1974 Line Records)
Before the Rainbow there was Elf. It was basically the same band – Ronnie James Dio on lead vocals, Mickey Lee Soule on keys, Gary Driscoll on drums, and Craig Gruber on bass. The one and only difference was Steve Edwards on guitar, who would have no place when Richie Blackmore came knocking a year later. Their second album, Carolina County Ball, was produced by Deep Purple’s Roger Glover. It’s fair to say that Dio hadn’t found his niche yet. With Mickey Lee Soule, Ronnie co-wrote every song, but was seeking a bouncier Guess Who direction at this point in time.
It sounds like Mardi Gras on the opening title track, with clarinets, trombones and trumpets accompanying the band on this “boogie-woogie Friday night”. Soule shines, ticking the keys with delicate intent. Heavy metal, this is not not! Not even close. There’s a guitar solo but it’s a secondary feature. Only at the end does the song pick up the pace. It’s actually a great tune, but anyone expecting dungeons and dragons had better head back to their gamesmaster for a new dice roll. Expect boogie.
“L.A. 59” opens like an old bar room, with a piano taking up all the space. The opening figure sounds like it’s emulating a train, which is probably a good guess. “Get me back to L.A., 59!” sings Ronnie, sounding a bit more like the mighty mite he would become. “Hello, hello sunshine!” Upbeat, with the guitar taking up more of the song this time. A great upbeat tune to start your day.
A little bit of a funky swing emerges on “Ain’t It All Amusing”, demonstrating the talents of the rhythm section in particular. Driscoll was no slouch and Gruber had no issue filling the bottom end with interesting vibes. This fun song really is about rhythm with a pinch of funk. It sounds a lot like Deep Purple Mk I, especially with the long percussion break that ends it.
“Happy”, which is ironically anything but, is a bit filler-ish. It’s Elf playing in a smokey nightclub and it’s all a bit repetitive. “Annie New Orleans” picks it up, with another Elf piano boogie-woogie. Whitesnake have also done songs of this nature in their early days. Then the awkwardly titled “Rocking Chair Rock ‘N’ Roll Blues”, which is a ballad more or less. It boasts a nice guitar solo and a laid back sound, but it’s going to have some reaching for the skip button. They shouldn’t, because three minutes in, a new riff arrives and transforms the song into another rockin’ boogie-woogie. Listen for some of Driscoll’s fun cowbell work on the back end too.
The one title that grabs everyone’s eye is “Rainbow”. Don’t get too excited. It doesn’t sound anything like Blackmore’s Rainbow; more like a a third rate tribute to The Band. The boogie-woogie is starting to wear a little thin, and same-samey now. “Do the Same Thing” is more like it. It sounds like a prototype to Rainbow’s “If You Don’t Like Rock ‘N’ Roll”. This allows the players to shine a bit more.
The album goes out on a cringey ballad called “Blanche”, with Dio singing about “Rainy days, rainy days” in a voice quite unlike the power he would later master. This is little more than a silly album outro; nothing to be taken seriously.
Every album and every band will have its defenders, but Elf was the least of Dio’s four main bands over the decades (counting Black Sabbath and Heaven and Hell as one band). Carolina County Ball lacks focus, and Glover doesn’t provide any punch in the stale production. The album rests on the songs and performances alone. Fortunately the band could play, though they seemed uncertain about who they wanted to be.
3/5 stars
mikeladano.com 