I’m done my series of Maiden reviews, so Aaron has challenged me to get out of my comfort zone. Β Together, we will be reviewing some of the albums he bought in Toronto during Record Store Excursion 2012. Β I’ve never heard any of these albums before, in fact I know almost nothing about most of these bands. Β Here’s part 1. Β Enjoy. (?)
Look for another Bidini feature on January 25.
Check out Aaron’s take here:
BIDINIBANDΒ – In The Rock Hall
I know nothing about Dave Bidini, I know nothing about this band, and I know nothing about this album. Β I didn’t cheat by reading up on them, or reading other reviews. Β I truly went into In The Rock Hall blindly with open ears.
It’s obvious these guys don’t give a crap about commercial songwriting. Β Anything considered standard, radio-friendly, or easy is tossed out the window in short order. Β The songs twist and turn through different, sometimes contradictory sounding sections. Β It sounds like it was painstakingly composed, piece by piece. Β This is all good — I like a challenging listen. Β It’s all done with a wink and a smile. Β They sound like they’d be very loud, live. Β It’s also obvious they love their ganja, as the subject comes up more than once!
The guitar work is striking. Β Like I said, I didn’t do any cheating to learn more about this album, so I have no idea who the guitar player is, but he or she has weaved together some unorthodox hooks. Β Riffs and melodies strike you from the speakers, demanding that you pay attention!
“I Wanna Go To Yemen” crosses acoustic riffing, latin-sounding clapping, unusual beats and electric guitars with some pretty funny lyrics:
I wanna go to Yemen,
I wanna go with you,
We’ll get high in the morning,
And in the afternoon
It defiesΒ categorization, which is a good thing. Β I’m not too keen on the singer’s flat vocals, I’m hoping they will grow on me. Β It reminds me of Pavement, a band I’m not too into. Β But it demanded a second listen, on which it grew further.
“On Camoragh Lake” starts with annoying beeps andΒ gratuitousΒ “fucks”. Β It’s pretty tuneless until you get to the chorus, which features some nice electric chords and female backing vocals. Β The song takes a turn around the 2 minute mark, getting a bit more passionate and noisy. Β It has some guitar squeaking that would make both Joe Satriani and Tom Morello happy. Β This annoying song gets more and more catchy as it goes on. Β It grows on you, with more listens.
Third is “Big Men Go Fast on the Water” (well, it was true for Vince Neil)! Β This is the most melodic and straightforward tune thus far, very enjoyable. Β This is the first song I can say I truly enjoyed from start to finish on first listen.
Another great tune follows, the passionate “Last of the Big Dead Things”. Β This dark, acoustic, beautiful tune wasΒ instantaneous. Β But just when you think you know what’s going to happen next, they go into a shouted section at 3 minutes, and then a quiet whisper.
“Needle Beach / Outdoor Motors” has a vague (but only vague) surf-rock sound, but it’s more distorted and twisty/turny than that. Β I’m not sure why the band seems to be obsessed with water themes, but hey, it’s all good. Β This one’s a bit too odd to get on first listen, but it does hit a catchy vocal part towards the end.
Better is “Hey Paul and Donna”, a nice acoustic one with a great chorus. Β “Hey Paul and Donna, I’m glad you took the train to Taranna!” Β That’s Toronto, for those who don’t know! Β It has a vintage 1960’s sound, and is probably the simplest, instantly catchy song on the album.
“Popcorn” features some intricate catchy guitar licks. Β It’s also a pretty simple catchy tune, the melody doesn’t do much for me, but that guitar part is truly great. Β I wish I could play that effortlessly. Β At 2:40 it takes another twist, with female vocals, almost sounding Christmas-carol-y.
Distorted robot vocals usher in “The Best Thing About The 80’s Was You”, complete with apropos drum programs. Β If you like 80’s music, this is a whimsical homage. Β If you don’t, like me, this one built for the skip button. Β It’s all tongue in cheek, but it’s not for me. Β “‘The Final Countdown’, the 80’s was you!”
There’s nothing simple about “Eunoia”, a 10 minute monster. Β It starts as a poem, with Tom Waits-esque backing music and noise. Β Then it goes into some nice guitar chords and understated vocal melody. Β It’s powerful and melodic. Β As you can imagine, it has multiple sections, each with some incredible guitar work, demanding that I pay attention. Β Just when I’m getting tired of one section, it twists into something else.
Up next is the percussive “Earth (Revisited)”, a humourous retelling of human history. Β It’s anchored by relentless drumming, and plenty of ooh’s and ahh’s.
The album closes with another long one, the title track, “In The Rock Hall”. Β Somewhat obviously, this one is about the Hall of Fame in Cleveland, but with a tongue in cheek. Β The lyrics are amusing, musically I felt like we’d already visited this territory.
Coming up with a simple rating is not easy. Β One cannot overlook the chops, the unorthodox stylings, the variety, and the refusal to keep things simple. Β On the other hand, I found the ooh’s, ahh’s, and la-la-la’s tiring, as well as the perpetually flat lead vocals. Β I don’t know how often I’d want to come back to this one. Β Striking a balance, I’ll rate In The Rock Hall:
3/5 stars
MIKE AND AARON GO TO TORONTO
















You must be logged in to post a comment.