Welcome to a series of posts related to Halloween 2024! Holen has written some guest posts, and I have my own bag of treats planned. Enjoy!
RECORD STORE TALES #1158: I dated a witch!
A sequel to #904: 2000 Dates and #616: None of My Exes Live in Texas
I have held off telling this tale long enough! There are many reasons why I haven’t told this story until now, but here are the two main ones:
- I didn’t want to upset my grandmother.
- I don’t know anything about witchcraft at all, therefore I don’t want to seem like I’m making fun of someone’s religion.
However, I also think it’s amusing to say the sentence, “I dated a witch once”. So here we go.
I explained in Record Store Tales #904: 2000 Dates, I did a lot of online dating in the year 2000. Every time, it seemed the girl had something unique about her. For example:
- One girl was the cousin of Haywire singer Paul MacAusland, and suffered from I osteogenesis imperfecta, the same disease that affected Mr. Glass in the Unbreakable trilogy. We went out once, and she wasn’t into me.
- Another girl was in AA and I actually attended a meeting with her, which was a bad idea. We went out a few times. She wasn’t sure if she wanted a friend or a boyfriend, so I stopped calling her.
- One was legally blind! She got into that movie The Cell with Jennifer Lopez and Vincent D’onofrio for free. She was starting a new life in a new town and I don’t think I was her best prospect. I stopped hearing from her, until one day she accidentally emailed me. I think we went out twice total. She had awesome black dreads.
This story is about none of those women.
Cynthia was from Toronto. She shared her surname with a prominent Star Trek character. She was into Sloan and A Perfect Circle. She took horrible care of her CDs. We wanted to listen to music, and I suggested 4 Nights at the Palais Royale by Sloan, but the discs were all mixed up in her collection. I knew it wasn’t going to work out.
We had one day together. I drove up to Toronto, got lost, and had a huge panic attack on my way there. No GPS, but I did have a cell phone. That was actually the end right there. It had nothing to do with her. It was the drive. I knew I’d never do that drive again.
Besides listening to music, I watched Cynthia work. She was an online psychic. I’m a sceptic, but the kind that would like to be convinced. She got on her computer, opened a word file, and began responding to emails. She scrolled through her word file, found a paragraph she liked, and hit “copy”. “This one will work,” she said. She had all her “psychic” readings pre-written; she just selected one that applied to the question. “I do real ones sometimes,” she justified to me. Sometimes. Not that night though.
We went for a walk, we talked, and Cynthia tried to explain her religion to me. She was a “weather witch”, she told me. She practiced Wicca. Wicca and witchcraft, she explained, were not interchangeable terms, but she was both. I was pretty clear that I was comfortable where I was spiritually, but hey, cool. I very much had a “you do you” attitude when it came to religion. We were both raised Catholic, so we had that in common. She had two roommates, also Wiccan. They had a picture up in their main entrance of their horned god, which was interesting, but they didn’t laugh when I commented that their god appeared “horny”. Come on, cut the new guy some slack!
I made it home on Highway 401 in one piece. I knew I’d never be going back. It was a matter of telling her. She did not take it well.
Cynthia had made for me a little magic pouch to protect me on the highway. When I told her I could not do that drive again, she was quite upset. “I’ll take the bus to you!” she offered. There were tears…I felt awful. I had described her as a “stage 5 clinger” before, which is unkind but not untrue. It was the first time I had experienced something like this. I went from indifferent dates, to this!
I went out the night of that phone call with some friends to a round of mini-golf. It helped me get my mind off things. I shared that I was slightly afraid she’d cast a spell on me. You always say “Oh but magic and witches aren’t real,” but I thought, “Cynthia didn’t think so.” What’s real? And what the hell did I know at age 28? We laughed a lot during that round of mini-golf, but then my friend Will prank called my car phone pretending to be an angry friend of Cynthia’s. That took some calming down after. Later, I was teased at a staff party by my co-workers about the kinds of spells she would put on me for dumping her. You can see why I haven’t told this story before.
Sometimes I wonder what happened to all these people I went out with during that period of time. Married, with adult kids now? Do they even remember me? I’m the one writing all this; maybe I’m the clinger after all.





