RECORD STORE TALES #1109: “Marillion Sucks”
Friends, what would you do if you ordered a used CD from a small chain, only to find somebody defaced the artwork with black magic marker before sending to you? What if that defacement was specifically aimed at you?
My love of Marillion was known far and wide at the Record Store. Nobody else liked Marillion. I’d play them when I could, but everybody I worked with hated Marillion.
Everybody.
But I never found out who hated Marillion so much that they would ruin a CD just to tell me that “Marillion sucks”.
I wish I had taken a picture, but here’s the story. After I quit the Record Store and became a regular customer, I still received preferential treatment for a few months. They would often set stuff aside for me and call me asking if I wanted it. That was very cool of them. They didn’t have to do that. Other times, I received treatment that was simply unacceptable.
One day in 2006, a few months after quitting, I placed an online order for some used CDs. Free shipping, no fuss no muss. I found three discs I wanted. One of them, which I was buying just “for the collection” was Gene Simmons’ spoken word CD, Speaking in Tongues. I didn’t plan on playing it every day, but I did plan on cherishing it as part of my Kiss collection. Everyone at that store knew my favourite band in the world was Kiss. They all hated Kiss about as much as Marillion. That said, I ordered Speaking in Tongues and awaited the arrival of my mail.
Discs from my old store often arrived in broken cases; that was par for the course. They also often arrived more scratched than I liked, but I wasn’t going to be as picky about what I bought as I was when I worked there. What was unacceptable and tantamount to sabotage was what I saw when I got my Simmons disc.
Everything appeared fine. The case was cracked, the disc was a little scuffy, but it should play fine, right?
I never got that far.
After removing the disc from the case, I saw that someone wrote on the inside back cover “MARILLION SUCKS” in big, black indelible magic marker.
Hah, hah. Funny.
Who does that to someone they know is a collector? Who does that to someone they obviously knew personally, since they knew I loved Marillion?
I never found out. I complained and nobody ever told me. I returned the disc immediately, unplayed. I was really pissed off.
The fact that this happened at a Record Store that preached “professionalism” was absolutely shocking. I remember getting in shit for telling a customer I hated Radiohead when asked! Did this person get in shit for writing “MARILLION SUCKS” on my CD?
I wonder if anyone will ever own up and tell me who wrecked my Simmons CD. I doubt it.






