classic rock

REVIEW: KISS – 40 (Japanese import with bonus track)

NEW RELEASE

KISS – 40 (2014 Universal Japan)

Alright people. I got a question for everybody here (and I didn’t forget about you people upstairs neither, woah yeah!). ย How many of you people believe in rock and roll?

If you believe in rock and roll, like you say you believe in rock-and-ro-oh-oll, then you know that 2014 is the 40th anniversary of the very first Kiss album. ย Gene Simmons believes in rock and roll. ย So does Universal music. ย They believe in rock and roll’s ability to fill their pockets again and again. ย  As fans, we have learned to accept this. ย You don’t have to buy every re-package and reissue that comes out; we all choose which releases to buy based on our wants and budgets.

Unreleased music is a top priority for me, so seeing Kiss 40 coming out with a number of unreleased tracks, I was excited about this release. ย I bought the Japanese edition from the folks over at CD Japan, for the Japanese exclusive bonus track. ย I’ll talk about that track in a bit, for now I want to express how happy I am with Kiss 40, as a compilation aimed at fans both new and old.

Sets like this are tricky. ย You have to include familiar versions of familiar hits for the people buying their first Kiss CD. ย You have to include value to the cantankerous old fan, and present the old songs in novel ways. ย What Kiss and Universal chose to do was include one song from every Kiss album, including every live album. ย Sprinkled into that are the unreleased songs.

High points:

I love that they used the Paul Stanley version of “God of Thunder”, the fast one. ย Marko Fox has been using that as his theme song on his show for a while, and I’ve really grown to love this version. ย All four solo albums have a song included. ย (I would have preferred a harder song from Paul’s album, but “Hold Me, Touch Me” was the single after all.) ย Killers is represented, via “Down on Your Knees”. ย Not a bad song. ย I’m glad to have the radio edit of “Jungle”, finally. ย I never had that before, and “Jungle” probably wouldn’t be on the album if it wasn’t edited down from its full seven minutes. ย (Although not stated, “Psycho-Circus” is also edited to remove the “circus” intro.)

Low points:

The goal of including Kiss songs from every album also means that you have to hear “Let’s Put the X in Sex”. ย Although this would have been a great place to use a rarer remixed version, it’s just the same one from Smashes, Thrashes & Hits. ย Another total miss that is here is the dreadful “Nothing Can Keep Me From You”, from the Detroit Rock City soundtrack. ย Whyyyyy.

Nitty gritty details:

The first rarity is a 1977 Gene Simmons demo called “Reputation”. ย You can hear that aspects of this song later made it into other Gene Simmons compositions such as “Radioactive”. ย This is one of those song titles I’d read about for years, but have never heard until now. ย Cool. ย While the song is definitely a demo, and not quite as good as most finished Kiss songs, it does boast a cool dual guitar solo and rocking piano a-la “Christine Sixteen”.

KISS 40On the second CD are the rare live tracks. ย In addition to live songs sampled from You Wanted the Best, You Got the Best!!, Alive IV: Kiss Symphony and The Millenium Concert, there are rare ones here from Instant Live CDs. ย Instant Live CDs are live albums you buy at the concert, immediately after the concert — a souvenir of the show you just saw. ย Extras are then sold online. ย I have a handful myself, but nobody has all of them (at least, nobody I know of!). ย “Deuce”, “Cold Gin”, and “Crazy Crazy Nights” are all from these Instant Live albums. ย “Crazy Crazy Nights” is the one I was most interested in. ย Live performances of that song are scarce in my collection. ย It is from the Sonic Boom tour, and it’s pretty solid. ย The song is played in a lower key to accommodate Paul, who does pretty good anyway. ย Eric and Tommy help him out on the chorus. ย Thayer simplifies the original Kulick solo, adapting it to his style and keeping the key hooks intact. ย The result is a tasty guitar solo which is a cross of both players.

Finally, those lucky lucky fans in Japan got a brand new live song: ย “Hell or Hallelujah” recorded at Budokan. ย Although the song itself smokes, Paul’s voice is really sore on this one. ย (Both the intro and outro, which could have been neatly edited out, are really harsh.) The song includes the line, “No lies, no fakin’,” and that is totally appropriate, because this sounds 100% live and untouched. ย Gotta give ’em credit for not trying to fix Paul’s voice in the mix.

Notable omissions:

“Love Gun”, “Creatures of the Night”, “Hotter than Hell”, “I Stole Your Love”, “Rocket Ride”, “Sure Know Something”, “Hide Your Heart”, “Domino”.

The verdict:

Buy this CD. ย The concept of “one track per album” creates some interesting listening results. ย The ratio of rarities to hits keeps it fresh all the way through. ย And if you’re a Kiss fan absolutely get the Japanese version. ย Just go to CD Japan and order it.

4/5 stars

Disc One

  1. โ€˜Nothin To Loseโ€™
  2. โ€˜Let Me Go, Rock โ€˜Nโ€™ Rollโ€™
  3. โ€˜Cโ€™mon and Love Meโ€™
  4. โ€˜Rock And Roll All Niteโ€™ (Live)
  5. โ€˜God Of Thunderโ€™ (Demo)
  6. โ€˜Bethโ€™
  7. โ€˜Hard Luck Womanโ€™
  8. โ€˜Reputationโ€™ (Demo) โ€“ Previously Unreleased
  9. โ€˜Christine Sixteenโ€™
  10. โ€˜Shout It Out Loudโ€™ (Live)
  11. โ€˜Strutter โ€˜78โ€ฒ
  12. โ€˜You Matter To Meโ€™ (Peter Criss)
  13. โ€˜Radioactiveโ€™ (Gene Simmons)
  14. โ€˜New York Grooveโ€™ (Ace Frehley)
  15. โ€˜Hold Me, Touch Meโ€™ (Paul Stanley)
  16. โ€˜I Was Made For Lovinโ€™ Youโ€™ (Single Edit)
  17. โ€˜Shandiโ€™
  18. โ€˜A World Without Heroesโ€™
  19. โ€˜I Love It Loudโ€™
  20. โ€˜Down On Your Kneesโ€™
  21. โ€˜Lick It Upโ€™
  22. โ€˜Heavenโ€™s On Fire’

 

Disc Two

  1. โ€˜Tears Are Fallingโ€™
  2. โ€˜Reason To Liveโ€™
  3. โ€˜Letโ€™s Put The X In Sexโ€™
  4. โ€˜Foreverโ€™ (Remix)
  5. โ€˜God Gave Rock โ€˜Nโ€™ Roll To You IIโ€™
  6. โ€˜Unholyโ€™ (Live)
  7. โ€˜Do You Love Me?โ€™ (MTV Unplugged)
  8. โ€˜Room Serviceโ€™ (Live)
  9. โ€˜Jungleโ€™ (Radio Edit)
  10. โ€˜Psycho Circusโ€™
  11. โ€˜Nothing Can Keep Me From Youโ€™ (Detroit Rock City soundtrack)
  12. โ€˜Detroit Rock Cityโ€™ (Live)
  13. โ€˜Deuceโ€™ (Live 2004) โ€“ Unreleased commercially
  14. โ€˜Firehouseโ€™ (Live โ€“ 1999/2000)
  15. โ€˜Modern Day Delilahโ€™
  16. โ€˜Cold Ginโ€™ (Live 2009) โ€“ Unreleased commercially
  17. โ€˜Crazy Crazy Nightsโ€™ (Live 2010) โ€“ Unreleased commercially
  18. โ€˜Hell or Hallelujahโ€™
  19. โ€˜Hell or Hallelujahโ€™ (Live in Japan 2013) โ€“ Japanese bonus track

REVIEW: Europe – Out of this World (1988)

This one comes to you by request of Jompa Wilmenius!

EUROPE – Out of this World (1988 Epic)

So here I am, in the same place that I was 26 years ago when I first heardย Out of this World, by a band I just loved: ย Europe. ย It was late August of 1988. ย The location is a quaint wooden cottage north of Kincardine, Ontario. ย I bought this album at the local records & tapes store while on summer vacation. ย The problem with August in Kincardine is that it was a crummy time to be on vacation. ย It started to get cool in late August, dark and rainy. ย That August was a damp one, and I have lots of memories of being in this exact same location trying to wrap my head around Europe’s then-latest.

From the first single, it was obvious to my friends and I that Europe had mellowed somewhat. ย It seemed odd to me that a band of Europe’s stature would releaseย something mid-tempo and softer as a first single. ย But there was no questioning the quality of “Superstitious”. It remains one of Joey Tempest’s greatest compositions. ย This song has it all: ย A soulful vibe, anthemic Europe keyboards, an absolutely blazing guitar solo by Kee Marcello, and plenty of organ to go with this darker mellow vibe.

I don’t think this video did them any favors.

That considered, I expected the next song “Let the Good Times Rock” to sound more like upbeat, “old” Europe (which to me was The Final Countdown). ย Although it has some cool guitar hooks and fun lyrics, it’s more of aย laid backย dark n’ dirty grind. ย This furthered the feeling that Europe were softening a bit.

None of us were then aware that “Open Your Heart” was a remake of a song from 1984’s Wings of Tomorrow. Kee didn’t play on the orginal, so it’s cool to hear his take on it. ย Even though this song was a ballad, it was undoubtedly hit single quality. ย When this song failed to get any airplay here, I began to worry that Europe’s fortunes in this country were over. ย I could not fathom how the song had not become a massive hit. ย Europe were being ignored by the mainstream. ย It was a shame. ย I still think the re-recorded version is great. ย As I said in my review for Wings of Tomorrow, “I prefer the re-recorded version, because it includes an additional guitar part, really cool and catchy, immediately after the acoustic intro.”


“More Than Meets the Eye” has nothing to do with the Transformers, but it does consist of more dark, keyboard-oriented radio rock. ย It’s a very good song, but again, I was craving something more upbeat. ย There was still hit single potential here. ย “Coast to Coast” is equally good, but very soft. ย This is a mournful organ-backed anthem. It’s peaceful, just like this cottage by the lake. ย Quality-wise, this is top-notch. ย However we are now five songs into the A-side, without a really truly upbeat sounding rock song. ย The young me found this all a bit too depressing, though today I don’t mind the laid back vibes.

Then, finally! ย “Ready or Not”! ย A smoking rock song. ย Everything the album needed. ย When Joey sings, “Then rock me just a little more,” that’s exactly how I felt! ย Coming from Canada, I often wonder how Europe’s Swedish fans, who had been on board much longer, felt about Europe’s new musical direction.

Side B commenced with the elegant keyboards of “Sign of the Times”. ย The song feels highbrow, and perhaps musically it was too sophisticated for the tastes at the time. ย It’s an excellent song, another keyboard-drenched anthem. ย The shame of it is, the production (by Ron Nevison) robs the song of so much power. ย Some things he captures quite well, such as Mic Michaeli’s organ. ย Other things are weak by comparison. ย Kee’s lead tone sounds cold…just like this cottage used to be in late August…and the rhythm guitars are not present enough. ย The song could have had much more dynamics, heavy and soft, if the instruments were just recorded a little differently.

“Just the Beginning” isn’t anything special to me, a chorus without a song. ย This one you can skip, there are better songs to be had. ย “Never Say Die” is pretty good. ย It too lacks that upbeat feel that I’m craving on a Europe album, but it’s good enough for me. ย It has some great parts even if the whole isn’t all it should be. ย The organ and guitar solos, for example, are a lot of fun. ย Unfortunately “Lights and Shadows”, which follows, is just filler.

“Tower’s Callin'”, the penultimate song, is back to quality songwriting. ย Even though the song has a cool groove (badly recorded once again) and a killer chorus, the lyrics are completely incongruous to the mood of the music! ย The songs seem to be about an air disaster:

All set ready to go but little does he know
He ain’t comin’ back no more, no
All set ready to fly into that deep blue sky
Like so many times before
Now the tower’s callin’, there’s no reply
And there’s nothin’ they can do
Now the night is fallin’ before their eyes
Still no one’s comin’ through, callin’ F12

Or am I reading this with too much 2014 perspective? Perhaps the song is supposed to be more Twilight Zone in nature, a disappearing plane?

The final track is “Tomorrow”, a Joey Tempest piano piece that once again has to be one of his best compositions. It does close the album on a sad, rainy note…much like that August in ’88.

It’s obvious that I can’t separate my listening to Out of this World from feelings of nostalgia. For that reason, take my rating with a grain of salt. Although many may feel differently, I like this album. It has a weaker second side and way too many ballads, but Ron Nevison robbed the guitars of their thunder. The songwriting shines through on many tracks, as does the talent of the players. For those reasons:

4/5 stars

OUT OF THIS WORLD_0003

REVIEW: Judas Priest – Redeemer of Souls (2014 deluxe edition – Disc 2)

NEW RELEASE

Part 2 of 2:ย Yesterday I reviewed disc 1 of Redeemer of Souls. ย Today, the bonus disc!

JUDAS PRIESTย – Redeemer of Souls (2014 deluxe edition)

Sometimes a bonus CD is made up of obvious castaways. ย Other times, such as with the most recent Black Sabbath album, the bonus disc contains some serious gems. ย I don’t know why everybody wouldn’t just go and buy the “deluxe” editions to get the bonus CDs, relatively cheap as they are. ย  For whatever reason, deluxe editions with bonus CDs flood the stores today. ย Thankfully, Judas Priest put just as much effort and passion into these five songs as they did the 13 on disc 1 of Redeemer of Souls.

JPROS_0002“Snakebite” inhabits an 80’s-like Priest vibe. ย Dare I say it? ย This would have sounded at home on Ram It Down, but it’s better than that. ย “Tears of Blood” on the other hand reminds me of “The Sentinel”. ย This is one of my favourite songs on the whole Redeemer of Souls set. ย  There’s no reason a song like this shouldn’t be a single. ย I don’t know how songs like this are selected for a bonus CD on a deluxe edition. ย Granted, disc 1 of Redeemer is topped to the brim in quality.

Still in an 80’s Priest mold, “Creatures” boasts a catchy chorus within a heavy song. ย (The title “Creatures” is short for “Creatures of the Night”, so I’m pretty sure they shortened it to avert lawsuits by G. Simmons.) ย What is it that has injected this youthful rediscovery ofย classic Priest melodies and riffs? ย Has Richie Faulkner re-ignitied the passion for writing those kinds of songs?

“Bring It On” is quite different from the other songs on Redeemer, but it certainly shares classic metal traits with them. ย I could imagine a song like this going over quite well live. ย Once again I ask, how does a strong contender like this get sent to the bonus CD? ย “Bring It On” is a fist-pumper, pure and simple. ย It’s uncomplicated by flourishes or production.

Finally, as if “Beginning of the End” wasn’t a proper album closer, comes “Never Forget”. ย This quiet ballad is lyrically a poignant open letter of thanks to the fans:

We’ll play on to the end,
It’s not over, not over my friends,
We are together tonight,
Reunited for all our lives,
And we thank you all for it,
We will never forget.

Truthfully, this song gives me chills. ย I think Priest get their point across.

JPROS_0003Before making closing arguments, I just want to briefly talk about the packaging and production. ย I’m on record as being a fan of Mark Wilkinson, and his work here is primo. ย Drawing on past characters as the Angel, Painkiller, and even Marillion’s Torch, here comes the Redeemer of Souls. ย The art looks great on the embossed, metallic-looking outer cover.

Glenn Tipton and Mike Exeter produced Redeemer of Souls, and by and large I think they did a fantastic job of capturing all that is good about Judas Priest. ย I find the mix to sound muddy. ย Maybe the CD was mixed too loudly, or perhaps I’m just not playing it loud enough. ย All I know is that I have a hard time hearing subtleties.

If Redeemer of Souls goes down as the final Judas Priest studio album, let it be known that it is a dignified statement. ย The band clearly worked hard on it (not that they didn’t for Nostradamus). ย Early feedback from fans is that they are by and large very happy with it. ย This was in spite of some uninspiring early song previews. ย When you listen to Redeemer of Souls, you will understand that it is not about individual songs so much as about the entire body of songs. ย All 13 (or 18) tracks are part of a whole that is best enjoyed whole.

4.75/5 stars

REVIEW: Judas Priest – Redeemer of Souls (2014 deluxe edition – Disc 1)

NEW RELEASE

Part 1 of 2: ย Today, the album, tomorrow the bonus CD!

JUDAS PRIESTย – Redeemer of Souls (2014 deluxe edition)

Whenever a classic metal band loses a key original member this late in the game, fans would be forgiven for being skeptical. ย When KK Downing quit in 2011, the shockwaves could be felt on every metal message board in the world. ย KK said,ย “There were at least 21 reasons why I decided to quit,” and you have to respect the man’s wishes. ย It was hard to be optimistic about the future of Judas Priest (if there was to be any), but the band responded by hiring young Richie Faulkner (ex-Lauren Harris) who proceeded to inject a fresh bolt of electricity.

Filling a role on stage is one thing, and Faulkner did that ably (as proven on the band’s live Epitaph blu-ray). ย He also brought his own sound to the table. ย Creating new music is much harder to do. ย Faulkner has a writing credit (with Rob Halford and Glenn Tipton) on every track of Judas Priest’s new album Redeemer of Souls, and the result is possibly Priest’s strongest since Painkiller in 1990. ย Those who felt indifferent to 2008’s double Nostradamus CD should find plenty to like here.

JPROS_0007“Dragonaut” opens the album with a track almost reminiscent of ย Rob’s solo band Halford. ย For me the most important thing about this song is the classic sounding Priest guitar solos. ย It’s almost like they said, “Do you doubt us? ย Check out the new kid.” ย The solo break has a harmony section similar to “Freewheel Burning”, but both shredders (Tipton and Faulkner) have plenty of time to burn. ย “Dragonaut” is a good track, but compared with others on the album, it’s just one of many.

The title track is not that dissimilar to Nostradamus,ย sounding pretty much as latter-day Priest are expected to sound. ย Perhaps that’s why it didn’t blow me away when it was first previewed a while ago. ย Now that it has had time to grow on me, I consider it a favourite. ย It has a chorus, a riff, and a beat you can bang your head to. ย What more do you want? ย More solos? ย OK, no problem. ย Sounds like Glenn has that under control!

If you missed the classic sound of Priest of old, then “Halls of Valhalla” may please you, as it sounds as if it could have been written for Painkillerย (think “Hell Patrol”). ย Faulkner nails the classic Priest vibe, but it’s the riffs here that truly feel classic. ย Regardless of past experiments in sound and direction, there are certain guitar parts that simply sound Priest-ish, and Redeemer of Souls is loaded with them. ย Halford throws in a couple screams, while Scott Travis and Ian Hill create the patented Judas Priest back beat. ย “Halls of Valhalla” is the strongest song thus far.

“Sword of Damocles” is rhythmically different; the band slow it down a bit to let the song stomp. ย The chorus here is top-notch, and the track has a lot of light and shade to it. ย Even though it’s only five minutes in length, I’m inclined to use the word “epic” to describe it. ย Meanwhile “March of the Damned” has a bit of a groove to it, something not always associated with Judas Priest. ย The riff has some “Metal Gods” in its DNA, but melodically I’m thinking of Ozzy. ย Regardless, it’s a great mid-tempo groover that would be an obvious single. ย Then a really nice guitar harmony introduces “Down in Flames”, which is nothing like its intro. ย Judas Priest can do heavy music of every type, and “Down in Flames” is Priest doing hard rock. ย It’s the heavy side of hard rock, but the catchy chorus leaves no doubt. ย Richie and Glenn trade off solos just like KK used to do, and I’m glad Priest have discovered some new chemistry guitar-wise.

At the midway point of the album comes “Hell and Back”. ย A ballady intro is merely a fake-out, soon one of those grinding British Steel riffs takes over. ย This one doesn’t boast one of the best choruses, but luckily the riffs and groove are entertaining enough. ย It definitely sounds like classic Judas Priest in style. ย It also has a killer outro.

JPROS_0005“Cold Blooded” might be considered the “power ballad”. ย This one took the longest to grow on me, due to a similarity to some of the slower material on the Demolition CD. ย I like it more now; the verses and choruses are really strong. ย I think there will be a lot of people who pick this song as a favourite. ย The solos absolutely smoke.

Priest usually like to lay down one or two breakneck speed metal workouts. ย “Metalizer” is one of those fast tracks, like “Painkiller” or “Demonizer”. ย This requires a couple Halford screams, and Rob delivers, insomuch as his voice will allow. ย  Think Rob sucks now? ย Let’s hear you scream at age 62! ย Then, “Crossfire” also has a classic Priest vibe, but I’ll be damned if the “quiet” guitar lick in the song isn’t eerily similar to “I” by Black Sabbath. ย Who sang for Black Sabbath on the last two dates of their Dehumanizer tour? ย Rob Halford.

Regal riffing opens “Secrets of the Dead” which is yet another outstanding track. ย This one reminds me of “Laid to Rest”, off the first album by Rob Halford’s Fight. ย It doesn’t sound like Fight; it sounds like Judas Priest, but there is a clear similarity to the earlier song. ย I also hear a little bit of “Night Comes Down”, from Defenders of the Faith. ย Then, what better to follow a slow track than something fast and metallic? ย “Battle Cry” is pure, classic metal. ย  There is nothing that sucks about “Battle Cry”; it lays waste to the landscape and features one of Rob’s best vocals on the album.

The land has been scorched. ย Nothing remains but the fires and ashes of the past — so “Beginning of the End” is a perfect end to this CD. ย It is a slow and mellow epic with texture. ย I firmly believe that an album should feel like a journey with a beginning, middle and end. ย A song like this feels like an album closer by destiny.

After 13 tracks of timeless heavy metal, it is understandable if you’re exhausted by the sheer power of it all. ย It’sย over an hour of pretty much non-stop quality metal, so it is hard to believe that there’s yetย more! ย On the deluxe edition, that is. ย Five more to be exact and we’ll be taking a close look at them tomorrow.

As for the basic version of Redeemer of Souls?

4.75/5 stars

GUEST CONCERT REVIEW: Queen + Adam Lambert 7/13/2014

QUEEN +

GUEST REVIEW by “Boppin”

QUEEN + ADAM LAMBERT โ€“ Live, July 13 2014 at the Air Canada Center, Toronto

I have to start off this review by saying I love Queen. I have listened to more songs by Queen than almost any band ever. I am told when people I know hear Queen, Steve Miller Band, Black Sabbath or 80’s metal, they think of me. So the review you are about to read really pains me to write. But I have to be true to myself and review the band as I saw them last night.

I went to this concert expecting to hate every little bit of Adam Lambert. I hated him on American Idol. Yes, I know. I hate to admit it, but for a while I did watch that show. How, you say, can a died-in-the-wool metal head and 70’s hard rock lover watch American Idol? Well. To answer that question, my family time TV viewing was limited to the type of shows we could watch together. Having a young pre-teen in the house meant only watching family type shows when she was awake. And she loved American Idol. At first I liked Adam Lambert. He was not your typical contestant on that show. But then he started showing off his pipes too much, and it got annoying. All of the viewers knew precisely when he was going to wail, and we got sick of him.

Then I heard the news that he was going to be the next lead singer for Queen.

Queen and American Idol. That is sacrilege. This would be like Gary Cherone in Van Halen. It wouldn’t work. It couldn’t work.

However, it did.

I hate to say this, but the three shining spots of the concert last night really had nothing at all to do with the original line up of Queen.

First, Adam Lambert was actually great. If Freddie Mercury was incredible, then Adam Lambert was great. He was spot on. He was campy, in a Freddie kind of way, and his voice was in top shape.

Second, Neil Fairclough, the bass player they hired to replace the retired John Deacon was amazing. His stand up electric bass was the biggest bass I have ever seen. It sounded sweet. And then he let Roger Taylor use drumsticks to play the bass (a first for me).

Third, Rufus Tiger Taylor. He is the son of Roger Taylor. And he has some serious chops. I didn’t realize how good he was until my wife pointed out to me that he was better than his dad. And last night, he was.

The concert was going along great, and then Adam Lambert left the stage, and the show for me mostly fell apart.

Please don’t get me wrong I love Brian May, but he was mostly off last night. His entire night sounded about a half second behind. His finger work was slow. His guitar solo (which was roughly 30 minutes) was about 28 minutes too long. It started out with a few minutes of Pink Floyd , then onto some Zeppelin, back to Floyd. I don’t think he was trying to copy David Gilmour or Jimmy Page, but the elements were there. At least I hope he wasn’t trying to copy them because he was doing a piss poor version if he was. For a guy that has seen many guitar virtuosos over the years, this was like watching a Junior High guitar talent show. The worst part for me was when Brian May screwed up in โ€œBohemian Rhapsodyโ€. It was a real fingernails on the chalkboard moment for me.

During the song โ€œLove of My Lifeโ€, Brian moved down to the front of the stage alone with an acoustic guitar. He admits he is not a singer. Well, Brian we quickly figured out why. Your voice was awful. God awful. And you chose to have the audience sing the other half of the lyrics of the song. You could have heard a pin drop when the 100 or so people in the entire audience of 15,000 that actually knew the lyrics were singing (whispering?). Here’s a hint. Choose a song most of the audience knows if you want them to sing the lyrics for you, or put the lyrics up on a screen.

Coming from the area of the world where Neil Peart is from, and having seen Rush in concert many times (and more recently seeing how good Tommy Clufetos can bang the skins), the drumming of Roger Taylor was another let down. It wasn’t bad. It just didn’t wow me. But in 2014, solos really are passรฉ unless you are really amazing, and Roger Taylor was not. He does not have a great singing voice either, which really showed when he tried to fill in for David Bowie during โ€œUnder Pressureโ€.

His son is a real up and comer though, and I hope he finds his own way in the music industry. It seems especially tough on children of famous musicians.

After the horrible โ€œLove of My Lifeโ€, Brian May talked about space travel and how we were all going on a journey and we may never come back, then all of the musicians(other than Lambert) went to the front of the stage and did โ€œ’39โ€. Pardon me while I yawn.

Please Adam, come back and save us from this snooze fest. As the lights go down and the audience sees Adam there is a huge cheer.

However, after a couple of classic Queen songs, they forced him to sing a remix of a little known Freddie Mercury disco song called โ€œLove Killsโ€. He announced Queen was using this version in an upcoming album. In my opinion, they should do a new album with new material, perhaps throwing in a few B-sides of old material, or do a live album. They could include Freddie, Paul Rodgers, Freddie Tribute Concert songs and Adam. Just my two cents. Also in my opinion, the band had plenty of time to come out with this new album before the tour, but they didn’t. And all they had for sale at the swag booths were $40 T-shirts. I have enough T-shirts thanks. Not one CD or vinyl. Nothing.

The entire show for me was like โ€œbackwards dayโ€. I assumed Brian May and Roger Taylor would be the highlight of the show. I told my wife the only reason I am going was to hear Brian May. But the cast of nobodies were better.

I should end the review by stating the whole is better than the sum of its parts for Queen + Adam Lambert. When they are together doing classic Queen songs, they sound great. When they do solos, and off-key singing, it didn’t work.

If they had included 8-10 more songs, and skipped a lot of the solos, I would have rated it higher.

My wife summed up the concert when we got back to the car by stating she liked The Lady Gaga concert a few nights before better (No, thankfully I did not attend that one). I told her “Don’t say that!”

For me, Adam Lambert was 8.5/10, the band without Adam 4/10, so together the show was 7.5/10. Too bad. It could have been much better.

[This works out to 3.75/5 on the five-point LeBrain scale. ย Thank you Boppin for this amazing review! — LeBrain]

SETLIST:

  1. Now I’m Here
  2. Stone Cold Crazy
  3. Another One Bites the Dust
  4. Fat Bottomed Girls
  5. In the Lap of the Gods… Revisited
  6. Seven Seas of Rhye
  7. Killer Queen
  8. Somebody to Love
  9. I Want It All
  10. Love of My Life
  11. ’39
  12. These Are the Days of Our Lives
  13. Under Pressure
  14. Love Kills
  15. Who Wants to Live Forever
  16. Guitar Solo
  17. Tie Your Mother Down
  18. Radio Ga Ga
  19. Crazy Little Thing Called Love
  20. The Show Must Go On
  21. Bohemian Rhapsody
  22. Encore: We Will Rock You
  23. Encore: We Are the Champions

More QUEEN at mikeladano.com:
QUEEN – Queenโ€™s First E.P. (1988 EMI, originally 1976)
QUEEN + PAUL RODGERS โ€“ The Cosmos Rocks (2008, iTunes bonus tracks)
QUEEN + PAUL RODGERS – โ€Fire and Waterโ€ (2008 Amazon.com bonus track)
BRIAN MAY & FRIENDS – Star Fleet Project (1983 Capitol Records)

CO-REVIEW: Funky Junction – Play a Tribute to Deep Purple (1973)

AN INTERNET FIRST: ย LeBrain and the Heavy Metal OverloRd have combined forces to bring you our very first co-review! ย We have chosen the rare album album by Funky Junction — a little known outfit better recognized under the name Thin Lizzy! ย Perhaps you have heard of them.

For the purposes of this review, LeBrain will be in black and HMO will be in blue.

FUNKY JUNCTION –ย Play a Tribute to Deep Purple (1973 Damont)

HMO: I like a challenge. Ever since hearing about Mikeโ€™s โ€œHoly Grailโ€ list of rarities Iโ€™ve been determined to find some for him here in Scotland. Given that Iโ€™m Scottish, this obsession with Holy Grails probably makes me Sean Connery to his Indiana Jones. Or something like that. At any rate, Iโ€™ll be calling him โ€œJuniorโ€ from now on. I saw this record in Glasgowโ€™s Missing Records and, knowing the hidden Thin Lizzy connection, I emailed Mike to see if he had it. He replied that it was on his Holy Grail list! Ya dancer! On closer inspection, however, the shop-copy looked too scratched to be worth even the ยฃ2.50 asking price. But the discovery gave me hope that I might find a better copy for him onlineโ€ฆ and here it is!

LeBrain: The band on the front cover wasn’t them. Their names appear nowhere on the LP packaging. All we’re told on the record jacket is that Funky Junction “are an exciting new group that has the pulse of today.” But for all intents and purposes, Funky Junction was Thin Lizzy:

Phil Lynott โ€“ bass guitar
Brian Downey โ€“ drums
Eric Bell โ€“ guitar
Benny White โ€“ vocals
Dave Lennox โ€“ keyboards

Since Phil Lynott couldn’t sing Ian Gillan’s high notes, and since Thin Lizzy didn’t have a keyboard player, the band hired members of another Irish group called Elmer Fudd to record the album, which they did in one day!

IMG_20140709_211154
“Fireball” is one of my favourite Deep Purple tracks. Even though Eric Bell referred to singer Benny White as an “Ian Gillan” clone, I don’t hear that at all. A Rod Evans clone, perhaps. “Fireball” is largely based on the drums, so we’re in safe territory here. Brian Downey is one of the few drummers who could give Ian Paice a run for his money in 1973. Not a bad cover I suppose, if you’re eager to hear was “Fireball” would have sounded like with Rod Evans singing.

Totally agree with you on the singer. The guy is so Rod Evans he was probably wearing gold lamรฉ trousers while he was singing this. Itโ€™s an ok version in a โ€œpub covers bandโ€ sort-of way. Brian Downeyโ€™s drumming is impressive, Philโ€™s bass soloโ€ฆ not so much.

“Dan” (credited to the German business man, Leo Muller, that conceived of and financed this project) is brief guitar instrumental. It’s supposed to sound like “Danny Boy” in a Hendrixian style, and I suppose that’s the right ballpark. Eric Bell fans will dig it, but as a song…next!

I like Ericโ€™s tone here but itโ€™s a lazy arrangement: just playing the melody and wanging his bar every now and again. Itโ€™s definitely the most Lizzy-esque song here though.

Funky Junction settle into a light groove on “Black Night”. This is a pretty faithful cover. What I like about this performance is Eric Bell’s way of improvising his own guitar solo within the style that Blackmore set for this song. The organ solo however is pretty caveman by comparison to Jon Lord. Pretty stock cover.

Iโ€™m actually fairly impressed by how faithful this one is, and a good approximation of the sound too. Eric Bell and Brian Downey are still the classiest acts here but it doesnโ€™t have anywhere near the edge of the Purple original. Still, one of the more enjoyable outings here.

I like that I can hear Phil Lynott’s personal bass style on “Palamatoon” but the lame keyboards sound out of place on this album. I don’t know how to describe this instrumental original except to say that, as usual, Eric Bell’s soloing is a highlight.

Itโ€™s cool to hear Phil on this. His bass line reminded me of โ€œLittle Girl in Bloomโ€ a bit. Itโ€™s just a shame that this tune is so bad. Itโ€™s like Emerson Lake and Palmer but pissed as farts. John Peel once described ELP as โ€œa waste of talent and electricityโ€. He was wrong. But this song definitely is.

“Strange Kind of Woman” is pretty limp. Once again, if you were eager to hear this Purple classic performed by a Rod Evans clone, this is the one. Downey and Bell are the highlights of a pretty dull performance.

Iโ€™m finding the Rod Evans factor to be one of the more interesting aspects of this. If it wasnโ€™t so workaday you could almost imagine these are some long-lost Deep Purple sessions from before they gave poor Rod the heave-ho. But apart from the โ€œwhat if?โ€ fantasisingโ€ฆ dull.

IMG_20140709_211124

Side two commences with the Deep Purple Mk I hit, “Hush” (actually a Billy Joe Royal cover). I find this one irritating. The singer’s enunciation bugs me. Deep Purple decided to anchor their version with a long keyboard solo. Unfortunately Funky Junction struggle to make their solo as interesting.

I think I liked this one more than you, Junior. This and Black Night are the two best Purple covers here. Not very inspiring on record but if they were playing it live at a pub I think Iโ€™d get into it. Benny sounds totally at home here, finally giving it the full, glorious Rod Evans. Probably with bouffant hair and a frilly shirt now too! Gaunโ€™ yerselโ€™ big man!

Even though we all know “Rising Sun” is a cover of “House of the Rising Sun” (a traditional), here Leo Muller takes songwriting credit! I hope he enjoyed what little royalties he earned from the meager sales of this LP. This is another instrumental cover, with a snooze-inducing ending.

Cheeky scamp that Leo Muller, eh? Iโ€™m surprised he didnโ€™t just change his name to Traditional and watch the money flood in. Nice sound and a decent performance on this song but mostly goes in one ear and out the other.

I appreciate that Funky Junction chose to retain that noisy, messy intro to “Speed King”. I’m afraid that of all the songs, “Speed King” suffers the most from the inadequate singer. Fortunately the Lizzy guys are talented enough to play the tune properly.

Everything weโ€™ve mentioned previously seems to work against them on Speed King. The caveman keyboards, the tameness. And the poor Rod Evans impersonator sounding like all your worst Karaoke nightmares (but with the added embarrassment of those trousers). Itโ€™s cool that they included the noisy intro (I think Leo Muller wrote that) but this is the worst Purple version here by a good margin.

“Corina” closes the album, a vocal track credited to Muller. It’s a cool blues that fits in with a Deep Purple Mk I vibe. I don’t mind this track too much. It’s nothing special but at least it’s not overshadowed by a superior Deep Purple version.

An OK boogie. Itโ€™s still making me think of pubs mostly. The lead guitar is the best thing about this one.

2/5 stars. Recommended primarily to fans of Eric Bell.

2.5/5 stars. I agree with Mike but Iโ€™m going to throw in an extra half-point because I thought the Rod Evans impersonator was a hoot.

  1. “Fireball” (Ritchie Blackmore, Ian Gillan, Roger Glover, Jon Lord, Ian Paice)
  2. “Dan” (Leo Muller)
  3. “Black Night” (Blackmore, Gillan, Glover, Lord, Paice)
  4. “Palamatoon” (Muller)
  5. “Strange Kind of Woman” (Blackmore, Gillan, Glover, Lord, Paice)
  1. “Hush” (Joe South)
  2. “Rising Sun” (Muller)
  3. “Speed King” (Blackmore, Gillan, Glover, Lord, Paice)
  4. “Corina” (Muller)

REVIEW: Alice Cooper – Hey Stoopid (1991)

First of an Alice Cooper double shot! ย Tomorrow, The Last Temptation!

ACHS_0002ALICE COOPER โ€“ Hey Stoopid (1991 Sony)

When Hey Stoopid first came out in ’91, fans were still reeling from the disappointment (but commercial success) that was the Trash CD. Fans wanted Alice to get heavier and drop the cheese, and Hey Stoopid was a step in the right direction, to be fully realized on his next album The Last Temptation.

It was the era of the virtuoso, and Cooper certainly knows a good musician when he hears one. To me it was a stroke of genius to have Steve Vai and Joe Satriani record a guitar solo together for the first time, and on a song called “Feed My Frankenstein” no less! Guest shots byย Ozzy (barely audible, though), Nikki Sixx, Vinnie Moore, and Slash provided enough hype for the fans to salivate.

Songwriting-wise, Hey Stoopid was a step up from Trash. The title track with its lyrical warnings of drug abuse was a fun catchy rocker with a tasty Satriani solo. The solos on this album are all too brief. Still the players being as good as they are create solos that enhance each track. Other standouts include the mindblowing “Might As Well Be On Mars”, an epic Desmond Child song that just aches before it explodes on the choruses. “Die For You”, written by Alice with Motley Crue’s Sixx & Mars, as well as Jim Vallance, has a chorus that bores its way into your brain and stays there like a parasite.

There’s still a lot of filler, something that plagues almost Alice album from Goes To Hell through to Hey Stoopid. “Snakebite”, “Hurricane Years”, “Little By Little” and “Dirty Dreams” are all songs that Alice will never play live in concert, and for good reason.

Yet there are still lots of hidden gems on this CD, all the way through to the final track “Wind-Up Toy”. A song about insanity, as only Alice can do, it is something that really hearkens back to Welcome To My Nightmare. What’s this about “Steven”?

There are also a couple lesser known tracks that aren’t on the domestic CD that are worth tracking down: “It Rained All Night” is a slowy, groovy track that was a B-side but better than some of the ballads on the actual album. “Fire” was a Jimi Hendrix cover with some fiery (pun intended) guitar playing.

The most disappointing thing about Hey Stoopid is the production by the normally excellent Peter Collins. Yes, Trash was too glossy, and yes, Hey Stoopid toughens the sound with more guitars. However the background vocals in particular are so dense, so saccharine, that even Def Leppard would blush. They are credited to different groups of people, and clearly there are a lot of voices here creating this gigantic mush of sound. It’s too much. I much preferred when Alice stripped it down on Dirty Diamonds, an album that deserves much praise. In 1991, production values just seemed to go to this extreme — witness Europe’s Prisoners In Paradise CD for a similar sounding album.

Hey Stoopid was Alice attempting to find his footing again, and while it stumbled, it did pave the way for Last Temptation. If grunge didn’t wipe out hard rock later that year, maybe Hey Stoopid would be regarded more fondly.

3/5 stars. Not great, but certainly not a failure.

Promotional "Hey Stoopid" memo

Promotional “Hey Stoopid” memo

Part 300: Manic Nirvana

Do you own this?

MANIC

RECORD STORE TALES Part 300: Manic Nirvana

T-Rev has always been talented at building things. He built for me my first two CD towers, not to mention my cassette storage shelves built into my closet doors. No design was too elaborate. I liked a simple CD tower myself, just some shelves and some stain. T-Rev was always pushing himself to build something cooler. One of the best towers he ever built had side doors for VHS compartments, and a big black light to illuminate the whole thing. Inside the doors were stickers from some of his favourite bands. The whole thing was painted gray, it was a masterpiece.

By coincidence, T-Rev also owned a semi-rare copy of Robert Plantโ€™s 1990 solo album, Manic Nirvana. Both of us liked to collect โ€œrareโ€ versions of albums. T-Rev had a red digipack copy, with symbols embossed on the cover. Itโ€™s pretty hard to find, although we did see a couple copies float by in the Record Store. Thereโ€™s werenโ€™t any bonus tracks, but the rare packaging made it something desirable.

So whatโ€™s the connection between the CD tower and Manic Nirvana?

T-Rev was checking out the Plant CD one day, and happened to take a look at it under his black light. Lo and behold, suddenly symbols appeared on the cover, previously hidden! The front cover showed what appeared to be a big โ€œHโ€. The back and inside covers had their own symbols that showed under black light.

It was a mystery! The symbols didnโ€™t seem to have any meaning that we could discern. Maybe they were intentional, maybe not? Maybe they were just a byproduct of the manufacturing process. Other similar digipacks did not show anything special under a black light.

My questions regarding this CD are as follows:
1) Have you ever owned the red digipack version of Manic Nirvana?*
2) Have you ever looked at it under a black light?
3) WHAT DOES IT MEAN?

*Aaron discovered via the Discogs listing that this seems to be a promo release.

 

REVIEW: Journey – Revelation (2008 2CD/DVD edition, import with bonus track)

JOURNEY โ€“ Revelation (2008 Nomota)

Itโ€™s funny to surf the reviews on Amazon for this CD. โ€œSuper and Awesomeโ€ says one. โ€œBest Journey album since Escapeโ€ says another. (Really? Better than Frontiers?)

OK, cutting through the glowing fanboy reviews, let’s be dispassionate here. Journey hasn’t truly sounded like Journey since Steve Smith and Steve Perry left for good in the late 90’s. In my unassuming personal view, Trial By Fire from 1997 was the best Journey album since the glory days. They tried to replace Steve Perry with a clone singer named Steve Augeri on three releases (Arrival, Red 1, Generations) and the result was a generic band that sounded like (guess what) a Journey tribute band. The fact that the smooth-as-butter Steve Smith was gone didn’t help.

REVELATION_0006

Journey did what I thought was a really smart move afterwards. They brought in the brilliant veteran Jeff Scott Soto to sing, and there are some pretty awesome bootlegs out there of Journey with Soto singing. Soto was no Steve Perry, but a unique singer in his own right, loved by his own legion of fans for his powerful voice. But he was no replicant; no duplicate. ย The band actually fired him to bring in someone more Perry-like.

That person is Arnel Pineda, who has an incredible set of pipes. I mean this guy can sing! Unfortunately, Pineda’s been singing Journey pretty much his whole life. He’s a Perry clone. He’s Perry-lite. He’s an imitator. And you can tell. He lacks the character, the grit, the personality, the soul, and the experience of Steve Perry.

Also, let’s not forget that Steve Perry was one of the major Journey songwriters, and without him Neil Schon and Jonathan Cain are left to their own devices. The soul is still gone, the heart of Journey is still ripped out. Revelation is no comeback album. It’s another Journey-lite album, it sounds like the best Journey tribute band in the world, but still…just a tribute band.

Having said that, it’s not bad. It’s not a comeback, it’s more of the same. There are good songs here – “Never Walk Away” being the strongest. “Like A Sunshower” is a nice, generic ballad. “The Journey (Revelation)” is the most adventurous tune here, an instrumental where Schon gets to show his stuff, shredding and classing up the place several notches. The rest of the tunes are just nice. Pleasant Journey-esque ditties where you can tell Cain and Schon were saying, “Let’s write a Journey rocker,” or “Let’s write a Journey ballad”.

The album is roughly half new songs, half old. The second disc is entirely re-records with Arnel singing classic Journey tunes. It’s nice but certainly no replacement for Greatest Hits. It’s great that they tackled “Stone In Love” and “Be Good To Yourself” on here. The rest are the hits, and you know ’em and love ’em already so I won’t talk about them too much. Except to say, this is where you notice first and foremost that Steve Perry is missing. The nuances are not here, rendering this disc nothing more than a novelty.

There are two other re-records, both (oddly enough) from the Augeri era. One is the Japan-only “The Place in Your Heart” which I don’t have so I can’t comment on it. The other, which is on all versions of the CD, is “Faith In The Heartland”, one of the better songs from Generations. I’m guessing they did these two re-records because nobody heard Generations. “Faith In The Heartland” is probably better on Generations, sung by the guy who actually wrote it, Steve Augeri.

There is also a great bonus track on the Mexican edition: great song, loaded with atmosphere, called “Let It Take You Back”. It’s about nostalgia, ironically, but I can relate and it’s a great tune backed by a strong riff. One of the best tunes on the album. Track it down, you won’t be sorry.

REVELATION_0004

The Walmart exclusive edition has a really good DVD: live (in Vegas) performances with Arnel singing. “Mother, Father” shows that Arnel can sing. Man, can he sing! I think Journey at this point are a stronger band live than in the studio. Live, Arnel has more character and you’re just in awe of the man’s pipes. This is a good DVD. And for free, it’s worth the price of admission.

So there you have it. Ignore the fanboys and let’s be unbiased here. This isn’t the Journey comeback we hoped for. It’s just another medium-rare Journey album. Until Perry comes back (and let’s face it, he has to one day) and records an album as great and progressive as Trial By Fire, this is a tired band spinnin’ tires.

3/5 stars

DVD:

  1. “Sky Light”
  2. “Any Way You Want It”
  3. “Wheel in the Sky”
  4. “Lights”
  5. “After All These Years”
  6. “Never Walk Away”
  7. “Open Arms (Prelude)”
  8. “Open Arms”
  9. “Mother, Father”
  10. “Wildest Dream”
  11. “Separate Ways (Worlds Apart)”
  12. “Faithfully”
  13. “Don’t Stop Believin'”
  14. “Be Good to Yourself”

REVIEW: Deep Purple – Made In Japan (4CD/1 DVD box set) Part 3

NEW RELEASE: Part 3

This box set is so massive, I needed to review it in three installments. ย The first two can be found here:
DEEP PURPLE – Made In Japan Part 1
DEEP PURPLE – Made In Japan Part 2

DEEP PURPLE – Made In Japan (2014 limited edition Super Deluxe box set)

“Smoke on the Water” Japanese 7″ promo. ย This is a reproduction of a rare Japanese promo single from 1972, sleeve and all. ย It is pressed on heavy 70 gram vinyl, a treat indeed. ย It features the promotional single edit of the studio version, and an edit of the Made In Japan version on the other side. ย  The studio edit is available on plenty of releases, such as Singles A’s and B’s. ย The live edit is one that I don’t think I owned prior to this. ย I actually enjoy something like this; it’s interesting to see where and how they did the edits, from a technical point of view.

Including a 7″ single in a box set of this size is something I wholeheartedly support. ย Not only do I love the vinyl format, but when you spend this much money ($115 Canadian) in one place, you deserve something extra. ย A lot of the stuff included in box sets these days, even in this box set, amounts to nothing more than paper. ย Music trumps packaging, so I’ll always take something like a bonus vinyl, especially when it has an exclusive track on it.

Interestingly, on this printing, the times for the two tracks are reversed. ย The live version is the longer, not the shorter as the label suggests.


LORDDVD: ย Made In Japan: The Rise of Deep Purple MKII and more.

This hour-long documentary consists of new and archival footage and interviews, assembled into a narrative. ย Old footage of Deep Purple MKI begins our story. ย The shortcomings of this lineup led the core members of Ian Paice, Jon Lord, and Ritchie Blackmore to seek new bandmates. ย They had gone as far as they could musically with Nick Simper (bass) and Rod Evans (vocals). ย In stepped Roger Glover and rock’s greatest screamer, Ian Gillan. ย Then, the big albums: ย In Rock, Fireball, and Machine Head.

Strangely, it was a tax loophole that led to Machine Head. It was expected that the fortunes of the band would only rise, butย British tax laws would keep them all paupers. ย If they became tax exiles, and wrote and recorded in mainland Europe, they would not be taxed. ย This led them to Montreux, Switzerland. ย According to Claude Nobs, they were planning on recording an album called Made In Switzerland. ย Nobs invited them to record at the local casino, and the circumstances of this have been well documented. ย A Frank Zappa concert that night was attended by Deep Purple and Nobs. ย Someone fired a flare gun into the bamboo ceiling, and the place went up in smoke. ย This DVD has the audio of Zappa asking the audience to leave!

The placeย did indeed burn to the ground. ย Luckily Deep Purple had not yet moved in their gear, or it too would be gone. ย Next they tried recording in a small theater, but noise complaints caused them to move again. ย It took almost a week to find the Grand Hotel, which was closed for the winter. ย Perfect. ย The results speak for themselves. ย Machine Head is the classic Deep Purple album. ย But according to Blackmore, it was Made In Japan that made them a phenomenon. ย It was a live album that they didn’t want to do, but could not have regretted doing.

Bruce Dickinson, James Hetfield, Lars Ulrich, and more show up to discuss the impact of Made In Japan on themselves. ย Dickinson points out that the remarkable thing is that Made In Japan is 100% live. ย There are no overdubs. ย Martin Birch managed to capture it raw. ย There’s a lot of great footage here; live footage, showing the interplay of the band.

IMG_20140607_062755

Next, the band headed to Rome to record the difficult Who Do We Think We Are. ย Made In Japan had not even been released in America yet, only Japan, until mass importing of the record forcedย the label to release it. ย Unfortunately at the height of their powers, Ian Gillan and Ritchie Blackmore had a massive falling out. ย Ian resigned. ย Blackmore and Paice almost formed a trio with Phil Lynott. ย Glover was fired, which was a condition Blackmore set to stay in Deep Purple. ย A final Japanese tour was the last commitment of the band. ย Glover describes a cold atmosphere, and the tension in the air.

Glenn Hughes appears next, remembering a Trapeze gig attended by members of Deep Purple. ย He sussed out the reason for their attendance. ย Still, he did not expect to be asked to join. ย It was an emotional time for Glover. ย He saw his Deep Purple albums on top of the charts, yet with magazines printing pictures of their new lineup featuring David Coverdale and Glenn Hughes. ย Hughes reveals he was mistakenly sent awards for albums like Who Do We Think We Are. ย Glover felt deeply hurt but strove to be a professional.

As a Deep Purple fan who owns a lot of Deep Purple on video, I enjoyed this documentary. ย Although it has some footage that I had before, it also had a lot that I didn’t, such asย interviews that were new to me. ย Footage from Japan is a highlight. ย “Smoke on the Water” is presented almost in full (from the 17th), though it is very lo-fi.

Extras include a music video for “Smoke on the Water”, made up of footage from the documentary. ย “The Revolution” is a short film about rock music and counter-culture, focusing on Deep Purple while at Montreux in 1971. ย Much of this footage is in the main documentary. ย A bearded Gillan rips his way through “Speed King”, and the band are interviewed. ย There’s also a short German documentary from 1972, subtitled of course. ย I enjoyed the description of their stage attire: ย “intentionally scruffy hippie uniforms”. ย Finally, there is a 1973 performance of “Smoke”, but now I’ve really heard the song too many times. ย It’s the best footage though: full colour, pro-shot. ย Roger is wearing bright red platform shoes.

This DVD was adequate. ย The main documentary feature was re-watchable. ย “The Revolution” and the German doc, not so much. ย It’s too bad that the video content is only tangendentally related to Made In Japan. ย The DVD is really not much more than a supplement to the main feature.

IMG_20140603_173713Final words: ย The box set is rounded out by an excellent booklet, a reproduction of the Japanese tour program, a family tree, and a reproduction press release. ย Ultimately these things are just pieces of paper. ย Nobody would go out of their way to buy a reproduction of a pressย release.

As a boxed set of music, Made In Japan is a home run. ย This is the way they should have released it back in ’93, instead of the incomplete Live In Japan. ย I’ll hang onto my old 2 CD anniversary edition of Made In Japan, because I believe in keeping the original mix of something. ย It’s an historic piece, not to be discarded. ย When I want a briefer Deep Purple live experience, I’ll play that version of Made In Japan. ย When I want the full Monty, I’m listening to this box set. ย Not only is it the best release sonically, but it is the only complete release of all three Japanese shows.

As a celebratory boxed edition of a classic, I’m less satisfied. ย The DVD and the papers inside are things I will get less enjoyment from. ย If the DVD had included a feature on the making and remixing of this edition, I would have been more interested.

Still, I’m happy.

For the music: ย 5/5 stars

For the box overall: ย 4/5 stars