Previous Reading:
Record Store Tales #600: The Vault
Disk 1 Review
Disk 2 Review
Three discs in, and now we hit the holy grail of Kiss rarities, finally available in the Vault.
GENE SIMMONS – The Vault – Disk 3 (2018 Rhino)
In 1977, Kiss were in California and Gene Simmons went into the studio with Eddie and Alex Van Halen to record three new demos. Van Halen were once his proteges of course, and were eager to help. The Van Halen demo of “Christine Sixteen” has a noticeably different vibe on the drums, and Eddie’s solo was the template by which Ace Frehley’s was recorded. There is also a bridge that was later dropped on the final Kiss version. The outro Eddie guitars are overdubbed in a way unlike anything he’d do with Van Halen. 5/5
“Tunnel of Love” has the early embryo of the things Van Halen would later be known for. The technique is all there, but not the tone. These demos are as rough sounding as they come, and there was no effort put into getting Eddie a good guitar sound. But there he is, shredding his way into Kisstory. Alex is also immediately identifiable. Unfortunately, the lacking element here is in the liner notes. Gene spends more time talking about schmoozing than he does the song. He does relay the story of signing Van Halen and tearing up the contract, again! “Tunnel of Love” eventually made it onto Gene’s solo album, but the Van Halen demo is cooler. 5/5
“Got Love For Sale” almost starts like a Van Halen original. Gene’s heavy-handed approach on the bass is a contrast that the VH vibe. Still, this little three piece could have made for an interesting side gig. Of course, Eddie’s solo is the highlight, whammying and doing his thang. Shame his tone is so thin on these demos. It is amazing that these songs spent decades locked in the vault (literally), and we never got to hear them until this box set came out. Pretty cool. 4.5/5
Onto the 1980s and the Crazy Nights era. Bruce Kulick wrote “Hell Or High Water” with Gene, and this demo shows the song was a little tougher sounding in its demo form. Guitars were just a tad more prominent. The song is otherwise more or less intact. Sounds like Eric Carr on drums, but the liner notes rarely say for sure. Gene describes the direction as “meandering”, but with hindsight, a good song is a good song. 4/5
Gene prefers the Revenge era. “Domino” is the demo recorded with Silent Rage. Gene describes it with comparisons to ZZ Top, and you can hear that influence in the verses. The arrangement wasn’t final here, but the idea was a keeper. There are some cool differences, such as the “Kisses like the kiss of death!” line repeating three times at the end. I think Gene has performed it live that way before. 4/5
“Mad Dog” should be familiar to Kiss collectors. The demo was also included in Kiss’ Box Set. The main riff was later used in “Flaming Youth” on Destroyer, a better song. Ace Frehley on guitars, J.R. Smalling on drums. This raises an interesting question. How many of the songs in this box set should be considered Gene Simmons demos, and how many should be considered Kiss? This demo has appeared under both names now. Some songs in this box set have more Kiss members on them than some Kiss songs. It’s a fine line. 3.5/5
“Only You” is a box set highlight. This pre-Elder version has the lyrics that Doro Pesche would one day record in her cover. This is the best version of “Only You” there is. It is completely different after the first few verses, turning into a bopping groove with a piano lick anchoring it! This is the version Kiss should have recorded, though perhaps for Kiss Killers. In the liner notes, Gene explains that this was based on an earlier song called “Eskimo Sun” that we will eventually get to. Gene says the chords were built from an appreciation for George Harrison. Sounds like Ace Frehley on guitar, though Gene suggests in the liner notes that he recorded it without other members of Kiss. He goes out of his way to say that they rarely accepted his requests to play on his demos. There are sour grapes throughout the liner notes, which is unfortunate. Great song. 5/5
“True Confessions #2” has Katey Sagal among the backup singers. Some of these early demos have elements to them that should have carried over to the final versions. Gene’s more natural singing on this is one such example. It’s better this way than with the “monster” voice. The truth of the matter is Gene’s not a bad singer, OK? The monster voice is a bit much sometimes, and “True Confessions” proves it. Gene’s just more expressive and sounds more like a lead singer than a character with his natural voice. And that says it all. In the end, character was chosen over authenticity. 4/5
“Childhood’s End” is a very rough recording of the song that later ended up on Carnival of Souls. Though the title was lifted from Arthur C. Clarke’s groundbreaking novel, the lyrics are about a friend who committed suicide. This idea was also used in “Legends Never Die” from Disk 1. This particular version of “Childhood’s End” is unfinished and not nearly as compelling. It does include a breakdown that is not in the final version, but sounds similar to “Outromental”. This song needed a lot of work, and this demo is also really hard on the ears. 2.5/5
“Burning Up With Fever #2” is another demo with Ace and J.R. Smalling. It later ended up on Gene’s solo album. This version rocks harder with less funk. The funkiness of Gene’s solo album was sometimes a little off-putting, so this demo may be more your speed. 3.5/5
“Good Girl Gone Bad” later ended up on Crazy Nights, but this early version has Bruce Kulick and what sounds like a drum machine. It’s harder edged. Though the final song is one of the better tunes on the album, this earlier arrangement shows it could have been a more Kiss-like rocker. When they talk about compromises made to make Crazy Nights more commercial, this demo shows what was cut. Guitars! Shame the demo is so rough sonically, but keep in mind, nobody was saving these for eventual release on a box set. 3.5/5
“Trial By Fire” was one of Gene’s songs from the Asylum era, therefore this is one of the earliest things he recorded with Bruce Kulick. This was always one of Gene’s better songs from an era when he wasn’t writing a lot of great songs. This one has a different chorus of “Live fast, die young!” This wasn’t on an old bootleg tape I used to have of Gene’s Asylum demos. I would think this song was actually called “Live Fast Die Young” at this stage of composition. 3.5/5
A little more bass-heavy is the similar demo for “Secretly Cruel”, the other really good song that Gene did for Asylum. This one did need a little more work in the guitar hook department, which it did eventually get. Decent demo inclusion, though in this case the album version is the good one. 3/5
“Love ‘Em and Leave ‘Em Yeah”, also known and “Rock and Rolls Royce” is a demo idea written around Destroyer, and eventually released on Rock and Roll Over. It’s different from the 3:02 demo on the Destroyer box set. It’s unclear who is playing on this demo, but there’s an early guitar solo and full drums. 3.5/5
“Am I Losing My Mind” is another stab at the song that would become “Only You”. This demo is more “new wave” sounding, with programmed drums that sound somewhat dance-y. Then it goes into a completely different chorus that is kind of funky, and doesn’t particularly match. It is fascinating to hear how these songs evolve. And we’re not finished yet, because there are more branches on this musical tree to come later on in this box set. 3/5
Average score for this CD: A respectable 3.83/5
Disk 3 Track length and songwriters (from Wikipedia)
1. Christine Sixteen (VH Bros. Demo) (2:39) Simmons
2. Tunnel of Love (VH Bros. Demo) (3:32) Simmons
3. Got Love for Sale (VH Bros. Demo) (3:10) Simmons
4. Hell or High Water (Demo) (3:08) Simmons / Kulick
5. Domino (Demo) (3:46) Simmons
6. Mad Dog (Demo) (2:27) Simmons
7. Only You (Demo) (4:35) Simmons
8. True Confessions #2 (3:33) Simmons
9. Childhood’s End (Demo) (3:30) Simmons / Kulick / Thayer
10. Burning Up With Fever #2 (3:06) Simmons
11. Good Girl Gone Bad (Demo) (4:04) Simmons / Sigerson
12. Trial by Fire (Demo) (3:31) Simmons / Kulick
13. Secretly Cruel (Demo) (3:46) Simmons
14. Love ‘Em and Leave ‘Em Yeah (Demo) (2:18) Simmons
15. Am I Losing My Mind (2:52) Simmons








